Homemade Catalina Dressing Recipe

Homemade Catalina Dressing Recipe. This sweetheart dressing of the 1960’s comes to life in your own kitchen. It’s easy to make, ready in under 10 minutes, and bursting with layers of flavor that are totally irresistible. This dressing is famous for being drizzled over that Old Fashioned Taco Salad.

Homemade salad dressing and vinaigrettes are routinely very easy and quick to make and always better than store bought. And more times than not, you’ll have the ingredients you need on hand right there in your pantry. Some of our favorite dressing recipes are, Homemade Buttermilk Ranch Dressing, Sweet Red Wine Vinaigrette, and this recipe for Creamy Mustard Vinaigrette.

If you’ve never had Catalina salad dressing, adjectives that come to mind to describe the flavor are pizzaz, tangy, sweet, thick, luscious, creamy (yet dairy free) and just plain exciting.

So much better than the bottled version, and we’ve been drizzling it all week over a big bowl of salad greens for a quick side dish.  

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• The vibrant rich rusty color alone is alluring to the senses and a hint to it’s irresistible flavor.
• It takes about 15 minutes to make. Once the ingredients are gathered, just whisk and serve.
• It’s an easy make ahead dressing that you can pull out of the fridge when dinner is ready. And it will be ready to drizzle over any salad you toss together all week.
• You’ve probably already got everything in your pantry to make this recipe.

Ingredients You’ll Need

The line up of ingredients to make this Catalina dressing recipe brings to light the reason the end flavor result is so exuberant. Let’s take a look.

• Apple Cider Vinegar
• Ketchup (Catsup) A condiment with a perfect flavor blend of tomatoes and sugar. This is the base ingredient to build the dressing. Use your favorite brand.
• Olive Oil: Since we’re not making a delicate vinaigrette where the flavor of the olive is is important to the balance, just use a mild flavored extra virgin olive oil. I like to purchase the big bottle from Costco and this brand will work fine for this recipe. Save those expensive brands where a delicate fruity flavor will benefit lighter ingredients, like this simple classic Lemon Mustard Vinaigrette.
• Granulated Sugar
• Kosher Salt Kosher salt is preferred by chefs due to the fact that the salt is believed to penetrate a more pure salt flavor into food. Rather than sea salt, that tends to sit on top of the food. Save the sea salt for adjusting salt levels at the dinner table.
• Grated Sweet Onion: Use the large holes on a box grater to grate the onion. Small holes will create too much moisture in the grated onion and basically become mush.
• Chili Powder: A lively blend of spices that is usually used to season Chili Soup Recipes.
• Paprika
• Dried Yellow Mustard: Dried mustard is such a different flavor experience over prepared yellow mustard from a bottle. It brings a sharp bite and an overall additional dimension of excitement to the recipe.

These ingredients give this Catalina Dressing Recipe its appealing vibrant color and rich flavor.

Ingredient Subs and Swaps

• Vinegar: Cider vinegar is a all-around great vinegar for flavoring about anything where you need a “tang”. Red Wine Vinegar would be a good substitute here. And white vinegar, or Champagne Vinegar will also work well for this recipe.
• Paprika: Regular paprika is called for in this recipe. But try Smoked paprika to give it a little bit different flavor profile.
• Sugar: Substitute 1/3 cup of honey for the granulated sugar. Honey is sweeter than sugar, so you’ll need less.
• Onion: Substitute 1/2 teaspoon onion powder for grated onion.
• Oil: You can also use a neutral oil such as canola or vegetable oil.

Step by Step Instructions

Making this Catalina dressing recipe simply can’t get any easier than this.

• Step 1: Choose a mixing bowl that’s large enough to easily whisk ingredients without them spilling out. Add all of the ingredients and using good old fashioned elbow grease, whisk vigorously until well blended.

Pro Tips:

This recipe calls for grated onion. Grated onion blends well and delivers more onion flavor than chopped onion. It also brings a smoother texture. It somewhat “juices” the onion which again, distributes more pure onion flavor. The easiest way to grate an onion is to grab your box grater. Use the large holes. The smaller holes will produce too much of a mushy watery texture. Cut the onion in half, remove the paper skins and start grating the flesh.

FAQs, Catalina Dressing

Recipe For Catalina Salad Dressing

So don’t hesitate, give this Catalina Dressing Recipe a try. Drizzle it over your favorite bowl of salad greens, or make this classic Taco Salad recipe. A salad that the whole family will love.

Catalina Dressing is also a great partner for fresh fruit and greens for this Winter Citrus Salad.

And if you’re looking for more salad dressing recipes and salads, don’t miss my Salad Category. You’ll find lots of great recipes, including the most popular salad dressing recipe on my site for Creamy Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing.

Catalina Dressing Recipe…It’s What’s for your favorite tossed salad.

Related Recipes

This Catalina Dressing recipe was first published March of 2013, and updated December of 2021 with step by step instructions and better photos.